Note
MANAGEMENT OF ACUTE TRAUMATIC STRESS IN NUCLEAR
AND RADIOLOGICAL EMERGENCIES
Marina Vazquez,* Osvaldo Jordan,* Enrique Kuper,
†
Daniel Hernandez,*
Martin Galmarini,
‡
and Augusto Ferraro
‡
Abstract—In order to effectively respond to and minimize the
psychological impact following disasters, such as radio-nuclear
ones, it is essential to understand the mechanisms involved in
such conditions and how to prevent and treat the psychological
impacts, including those related to acute traumatic stress and
its consequences across life span. Radio-nuclear emergencies
may cause psychological traumatic stress, with its potentially
significant consequences in mental health, with both short and
long-term effects, which extend beyond the individuals directly
affected. Ionizing radiation cannot be perceived by human
senses and most people are unaware of the magnitude of its
effects, which could result in feelings of helplessness and
vulnerability. Those situations with a high degree of uncer-
tainty, regarding potential future health effects, are more
psychologically traumatic than others. The present century has
witnessed a steady increase in the number of publications
concerning the mental health impact of traumatic events,
showing the need of increasing the study of traumatic stress
and its impact on mental health. A prompt, planned and
effective response to manage disaster-induced acute traumatic
stress may prevent the evolutionary reactions of traumatic
stress into disorders or even chronic stress diseases that can
appear after a nuclear or radiological emergency.
Health Phys. 98(6):795–798; 2010
Key words: World Health Organization; emergencies, radio-
logical; emergency planning; health effects
INTRODUCTION
THERE WERE two relevant turning points in the qualitative
perception of the risk associated with the use of ionizing
radiation: the bombs of Hiroshima and Nagasaki, and the
Chernobyl nuclear power plant accident. Technological
disasters bring about psychological effects of varied
durability and intensity in exposed populations. Nuclear
and radiological disasters have been more likely to
induce chronic psychopathologies than other types of
disasters, such as storms, floods, and hurricanes. Studies
of radiological accidents at Chernobyl, Goia ˆnia, and
Three Mile Island have shown that the traumatic stress
and long-term psychological damage caused by the
release of radioactive material into the environment are
disproportionate to the actual damage inflicted (Baum et
al. 1983; Curado et al. 1991; Zafra et al. 2002; Bennett et
al. 2006; Bromet and Havenaar 2007). Several investi-
gations have shown increased levels of somatization
disorders, increased drug and alcohol abuse, increased
levels of suicidal/homicidal ideas, and that traumatic
stress is the most frequent disorder and one of the most
severe that may follow an event of this nature. Pirard et
al. (1998) reviews the epidemiological studies which
assess psychological and psychiatric consequences of the
Three Mile Island, Goia ˆnia, and Chernobyl accidents. It
shows, in different accidental and cultural contexts, a
statistically significant and durable increase of psycho-
logical symptoms in various exposed population groups.
Radiological and nuclear emergencies share com-
mon aspects and the perception of their risk tends to be
overestimated because
● People relate them to past accidental or catastrophic
situations such as Hiroshima and Chernobyl;
● They lead to very long-term consequences;
● They are related to little understood activities;
● The causative agent is not perceived by the senses;
● They can also affect unborn children, pregnant
women, children and future generations; and
● The control of the situation is beyond the individual, who
depends on other people’s decisions (lack of self control).
Classification of the victims
Primary victims are those who suffer from the “bio-
logical effects” of radiation while the secondary victims
may be relatives and friends of the primary victims.
* Nuclear Regulatory Authority, Av. Del Libertador 8250
(BNP1428) Buenos Aires, Argentina;
†
Neurobiological and Trau-
matic Bio-psycho-medical Center, Argentina;
‡
Ministry of Security
and Justice, Buenos Aires Government, Argentina.
For correspondence contact: Vazquez Marina, Emergency
Control Center, Nuclear Regulatory Authority, Av. Del Liberta-
dor 8250 (BNP1428) Buenos Aires, Argentina, or email at
mvazquez@cae.arn.gov.ar.
(Manuscript accepted 11 August 2009)
0017-9078/10/0
Copyright © 2010 Health Physics Society
DOI: 10.1097/HP.0b013e3181bbc742
795