AMERICAN JOURNAL OF SOCIAL AND MANAGEMENT SCIENCES
ISSN Print: 2156-1540, ISSN Online: 2151-1559, doi:10.5251/ajsms.2010.1.2.201.208
© 2010, ScienceHuβ, http://www.scihub.org/AJSMS
Solving the problem of infertility among Christians: A bioethical appraisal
Rev. Emeka C. Ekeke and Dr. Christian O. Uchegbue
University of Calabar, Calabar, Nigeria
Email: revekekemekus@yahoo.com, Phone: +2340837930856
ABSTRACT
Infertility has become a terrible cankerworm destroying the joy of many couples the world over.
Among Christians, this issue has grown to a monumental level so that many Christian couples
question God’s power and ability. Today many Christian couples could do anything either good or
bad to have children. This paper therefore examines some of the various biomedical approaches
through which the problem of infertility could be solved among Christians such as artificial womb,
artificial insemination, surrogacy, in-vitro fertilization and sperm and egg donation. The paper
recommends, among others, that every Christian couple should know that God is the giver of
children and look up to Him for direction and not plunge themselves into acts that they will regret
about in the future.
Keywords: Infertility, artificial, womb, Christians, surrogacy
INTRODUCTION
The issue of infertility or barrenness among couples
has become a critical problem today in the world.
The growth of infertility has led biotechnology
researchers into trying some new things to solve this
problem. This is why the idea of artificial womb,
which formerly existed in fiction, is now becoming a
reality. The practice of artificial insemination is now
the order of the day in many clinics and hospitals in
many countries such as United Kingdom, United
States of America, New Zealand, Germany, Norway,
India, Nigeria, South Africa and so many other
countries. The issue of surrogacy has not abated
despite so many critical issues surrounding it such as
the idea of depersonalizing reproduction by creating
“a separation of genetic, gestational, and social
parenthood” (Meinke, 2001: 2). Surrogacy has also
created a problem of benefit. This means that there
is a change of motive in having children, not for their
(children) sake, but for another’s benefit. The issue
of sperm and eggs donation to solve the problem of
infertility remains a critical problem especially among
Christian bioethical scholars. In this paper, our
intention is to carefully analyze all these issues,
showing their benefits and problems and why they
should either continue to flourish or should be abated
especially among Christians.
Artificial Womb or Uterus: In the field of
ectogenesis, an artificial womb or uterus is a
mechanism that is used to grow an embryo outside of
the body of a female organism that would normally
internally carry the embryo to term (Wikipedia, the
free encyclopedia 2009, “Artificial uterus” p.1). In
some cases, artificial womb serves as a replacement
organ, which could be used to assist women with
damaged or diseased womb to be able to conceive to
term. It is believed by researchers that since the
uterus is grown from the woman’s own endometrial
cells (the mucous membrane lining the uterus, which
becomes aggressively thicker and more glandular
and has an increased blood supply in the latter part
of the menstrual cycle) there would be minimal
chance of organ rejection. This prepares the
endometrium for implantation of the embryo, but if
this does not occur much of the endometrium breaks
down and is lost during menstruation. If pregnancy is
established, the endometrium (the membrane lining
the womb) becomes the decidual, which is shed after
birth.
This idea of an artificial womb first existed in science
fiction like the one depicted by Aldous Huxley in his
1932 novel, Brave New World. Huxley saw in the
future where children are grown in artificial wombs
before being decanted into the world. A similar
scenario is portrayed in Logan’s Run, where embryos
are extracted from impregnated women to be grown
in Maccano-breeder by a computer-controlled life-
support system. These and many more fictions
became the foundation for the research to see the
workability of having an artificial womb (Wikipedia…,
2009 “Artificial uterus” p.2).
Reynolds (2005-2009) narrates how the first primary
research into the engineering of an artificial uterus
was conducted by Dr. Hung-Ching Liu at the Cornell
University Center for Reproductive medicine and
infertility. She and her team observed that a fetus